Comparisonandanalysisof2biogasutilizationschemes

    4個方案的對比分析見表1。由表1可知，4種方案總收益相差不大，其中，方案1及方案2前期建設工程投入及運行維護費用較小，收益較大；方案3前期建設工程費用更小，且不存在運行維護成本，收益，但該方案存在較大安全隱患；方案4由于前期建設工程投入及運行維護成本高，雖然其收入為4個方案，但收益與前3個方案差別不大。    ThecomparativeanalysisofthefourschemesisshowninTable1.Itcanbeseenfromtable1thatthereislittledifferenceinthetotalbenefitsofthefourschemes.Amongthem,theinvestmentandoperationandmaintenancecostsofscheme1andscheme2arerelativelysmall,andthebenefitsarerelativelylarge;scheme3hastheminimumconstructioncosts,andthereisnooperationandmaintenancecosts,andthebenefitsarethelargest,buttherearerelativelylargepotentialsafetyhazardsinthescheme;scheme4hashighinvestmentandoperationandmaintenancecosts,althoughtheincomeisrelativelylowTheincomeofthefourschemesisthehighest,butthereislittledifferencebetweenthem.

    4種沼氣發電方案優缺點

    Advantagesanddisadvantagesoffourbiogaspowergenerationschemes

    3結論

    3conclusion

    方案1:沼氣經沼氣燃燒器回爐燃燒可回收沼氣熱量，增加了整廠的收益，且運行穩定、可靠。方案2:沼氣經回噴槍回爐燃燒收益相當于方案1,但當焚燒爐燃燒工況不穩定時，沼氣可能有點火燃燒不及時風險。方案3:將沼氣抽送至垃圾坑經濟性能更好，但綜合考慮垃圾本身產生的沼氣及被抽回的沼氣，沼氣濃度太高，且不易控制，增加了爆炸事故發生的可能性，故方案3存在安全隱患。方案4:沼氣熱利用效率，但設備、建設費用較高，且該方案沼氣須經過預處理，系統復雜，故障率較高。此外，上網發電需要增加升壓裝置，并派專人維護，人力及維護成本較高。由此可見，生活垃圾焚燒發電廠滲瀝液處理產生的沼氣，采用通過沼氣燃燒器回噴入爐焚燒的利用方案。   Scheme1:theheatofbiogascanberecoveredbyreturningthebiogasburnertothefurnace,increasingtheincomeofthewholeplant,andtheoperationisstableandreliable.Scheme2:thebenefitofbiogasreturningtothefurnacethroughthereturnlanceisequivalenttoscheme1,butwhenthecombustionconditionoftheincineratorisunstable,theremaybetheriskofdelayedignitionandcombustionofbiogas.Scheme3:theeconomicperformanceofpumpingbiogastothegarbagepitisthebest,butconsideringthebiogasproducedbythegarbageitselfandthebiogaspumpedback,theconcentrationofbiogasistoohighanddifficulttocontrol,whichincreasesthepossibilityofexplosionaccidents,soscheme3haspotentialsafetyhazards.Scheme4:thebiogasheatutilizationefficiencyisthehighest,buttheequipmentandconstructioncostsarehigh,andthebiogasinthisschememustbepretreated,sothesystemiscomplexandthefailurerateishigh.Inaddition,thegridpowergenerationneedstoincreasetheboosterdevice,andsendspecialpersonneltomaintain,sothecostofmanpowerandmaintenanceishigh.Itcanbeseenthatthebiogasproducedbyleachatetreatmentindomesticwasteincinerationpowerplantisbesttobeinjectedintothefurnacethroughbiogas